The
Orange Order in the 20th Century: A Comparative Analysis of Northern Ireland,
Scotland, Newfoundland and Ontario[1]
Dr. Eric P. Kaufmann, Dept. of Politics, University
of Southampton,
Southampton, U.K.
The Orange Order,
or Loyal Orange Institution (as it is officially known) is a voluntary
association that has played a pivotal organisational role for
British-Protestant dominant ethnic groups in Canada, Scotland, Northern
Ireland, and, to a lesser extent, northwest England. It continues to make
headlines in Northern Ireland due to conflicts arising from the July Twelfth
marching season. Indeed, the symbolism of the Orange Order is so interwoven
into the fabric of Irish history that the Irish Republic's tricolour proclaims
its goal of reuniting Orange and Green. In Canada, the Orange Order once
occupied a similar position as it does today in Northern Ireland. Today,
however, it is but a shadow of its former self. This discrepancy between two
modern societies offers us an important variation within one social movement.
Accordingly, the Orange Order serves as a lens through which we can focus on
processes of dominant ethnicity and voluntary association as they interact with
the forces of late modernity.
The Order has
never been the subject of primary social scientific investigation, though Ruth
Dudley Edwards' The Faithful Tribe
(1999) provides the first journalistic account for Northern Ireland and Cecil
Houston & William Smyth's The Sash
Canada Wore (1980) is an important historical-geographical work. However,
the latter book concentrates on the nineteenth century rise of the Orange
Order, and only speculates about the reasons why the Canadian Order declined in
the twentieth century. Other historical work on the Canadian Orange Order does
not address the question of twentieth century social change (Senior 1972;
Pennefather 1984). Some high-quality historical research has also
taken place in Britain and Ireland, but here again, the post-1939 period
remains neglected (Gray 1972; MacFarland 1990; Walker 1992, 1995; MacRaild
1998).
This paper will
address twentieth century Orangeism in comparative perspective. This primarily
entails consideration of the pattern of Orange membership in Northern Ireland,
Ontario, Newfoundland and central Scotland. Indeed, one of the more pragmatic
questions posed by the striking demise of Ontario's Orange Order is whether its
sharp decline in the twentieth century can yield any insight into the future of
the Ulster Orange Order. This would be of signal importance for the long-term direction
of the peace process, since the Orange element provides one of the bulwarks of
Unionist resistance to the Good Friday Agreement. Our approach, which attempts
to explain the impact of modernising processes, also requires an engagement
with theories of social change, ethnic change and social capital. Accordingly,
this paper promises to broaden our understanding of how dominant ethnic groups
are affected by techno-economic and cultural variants of modernisation.
Comparative
Loyalism: Canada and Northern Ireland
It is not the intent of this
work to account for the birth of Orangeism. However, few would contest the
notion that inter-ethnic conflict and rival versions of the past played a role
in the origins of this organisation. An interesting exercise in comparative
study is to examine the cultural similarities between the (historically)
strongest Orange locales: English Canada and Northern Ireland. Both were settler societies whose dominant group members
identified themselves not with any particular British ethnie (ie. Irish, Scottish, English), but as composite, ethnic Britons. In both societies,
competition with a Catholic ethnic opponent (French-Canadian, Irish-Catholic)
helped to reinforce the Protestant accent of the Loyalist group. Likewise, competition
with a Republican foe - the Americans for Canada and Catholic Nationalists in
Ireland - fortified the Imperial bond. Furthermore, the connection between the
Ulster-Protestants and Anglo-Canadians (or 'British Americans') extended to
demography: fully 25 percent of Canada's British population was Irish
Protestant in 1867, rendering Irish Protestants the most over-represented
British category. (Richard 1991:
44, 48, 83; Burnet 1972: 102-4; Buckner 1998: 11)
Both
Loyalist groups also faced similar ontological and political problems. Namely,
the task of maintaining a credibly 'British' identity in the face of neglect
from the mother country and each group's lack of identifiably 'British'
culture. Indeed, the English-Canadian struggle to be un-American parallels the
Ulster-Protestant struggle against Irishness. Given the similarity between
Anglo-Canadians and Ulster-Protestants, it is not surprising that the Orange
Order emerged as the leading social movement within both groups from the mid-nineteenth century onward. Finally, the
collapse of the British Empire after the 1950's was a blow which both groups
have struggled to come to terms with: Anglo-Canadians have variously embraced
multiculturalism and anti-establishment populism, while Ulster-Protestants have
increasingly attempted to establish a more 'home-grown' sense of ethnic
identity. (Dunn & Morgan 1994; Adamson [1982] 1991; Kaufmann 1997: 130;
Craith 2001)
The
Rise of the Orange Order in Canada
The Orange Order
developed as a fraternal society for the Protestant population in Ireland after
1795. It rose in response to the impending threat of Irish independence posed
by the revolutionary coalition between the liberal-Protestant United Irishmen
and the Catholic Defender movement. In the following three decades, Irish
immigration and its attendant sectarian divisions established Orangeism in the
western lowlands of Scotland and the north-west of England. Thus Orangeism
existed within a Unionist ethnic and political environment in Northern Ireland,
Scotland (particularly in the western part of the central belt) and areas
adjacent to Liverpool in north-west England. (Gallagher 1987; MacFarland 1990;
McCrone 1992; MacRaild 1998) Nonetheless, since the organisation served
instrumental and fraternal functions, one should not assume that the spread of
the movement merely reflected the aforementioned cultural-political conditions.
The processes
which spawned the rise of the Orange Order in the British Isles operated with
equal, or greater, vigour, in Canada. Few contemporary English-speaking
Canadians realise that as many as one in three adult Protestant males in
Ontario passed through the ranks of the Orange Order between 1870 and 1920
while the influential Ladies' Orange Benevolent Association (LOBA) proved that
the principles of the Order were not gender-specific. The Canadian Order was
not an Irish organisation, but instead brought together several ethnic
components of English Canada's Protestant majority. (Houston & Smyth 1980:
84, 95-6, 104) Founded in Ontario in the early years of the nineteenth century
as an association for Irish Protestant immigrants, by the 1860s, the Orange
Order had become firmly 'native' in outlook.
Its power was
centred in Ontario and New Brunswick, but the Order maintained a strong network
of lodges in all provinces[2].
The large-scale immigration of Irish Protestants in 1820-65 gave the
organisation its initial impetus in Ontario and New Brunswick. In Newfoundland,
however, the Order took root amongst a native-born population of West Country
English derivation. First introduced by Prince Edward Islanders and Nova
Scotians travelling by ship to the western Port-au-Port peninsula in the early
1860's, Orangeism quickly began to thrive within the active Protestant-Catholic
matrix of this British maritime colony. (Senior 1960)
Later, in the
nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, both the Canadian and Newfoundland
Orders benefited from an imperialist political climate. This was manifested
through a Britannic nationalist exuberance for both Empire and the 'civilizing'
mission of the Protestant crusade. Britannic nationalism was bolstered by both
a romantic Loyalist Revival in the post-Confederation period as well as a
series of conflicts in which Orangemen featured prominently as bastions of
British Loyalty. These included the Rebellions of 1837-8, the Crimean War
(1854-6), the Riel Rebellions (1869-70, 1885), the Manitoba Schools Question
(1890), the Boer War (1899-1902) and the First World War (1914-18). (Rasporich
1968: 140-56; Senior 1972: 62, 71, 96; Berger 1969)
Canadian
imperialist fervour far exceeded that of the British metropole - where
imperialism divided liberals (allied to the cause of Irish home rule) and
Tories. For instance, the Royal Tour of Canada in 1901 drew crowds that regularly
exceeded the local population. 'Everywhere the crowds were huge and
enthusiastic,' writes Philip Buckner. 'In Toronto, between 200,000 and 250,000
people lined the streets.' (Buckner 1998: 12) Meanwhile, Orange expansion in
the nineteenth century was so great that the Order had become larger in Canada
than in Ireland by 1900. (See figure 1) When we consider that the population of
English-speaking Canada was just 3.8 million at this time, we must conclude
that English Canada was as Orange a society as Ireland. (Buckner 1998: 14)
Furthermore, the concentration of membership in Ontario, New Brunswick and
Newfoundland compared favourably, as we shall see, with Orange density in the
nine counties of Ulster.
The Order's
mainstream nature and political influence as a bastion of popular Toryism is
attested to by the many politicians who passed through its ranks, from Sir John
A. Macdonald and Oliver Mowat in the mid-nineteenth century to prime minister
John Diefenbaker, Newfoundland premier Joey Smallwood and Toronto mayor Leslie
Saunders in the mid-twentieth. (Senior 1972) In Ontario, the Order was
influential both at Queen's Park and on Toronto city council, enforcing
sabbatarian ordinances and temperance laws that influenced the character of
'Toronto the Good' until the Second World War. Indeed, the City of Toronto
('the Belfast of Canada') only acquired its first non-Orange councillor in the
1930s. In Newfoundland, meanwhile, many credit the Order with tipping the 1948
vote in favour of Confederation. (Fitzgerald 1998: 3; Jamieson 1991: 103)
The
Decline of the Orange Order in Canada
By the third
decade of the new century, Order membership growth in Toronto was failing to
keep pace with the city's skyrocketing population. (Houston & Smyth 1980:
154-7, 162-80) And from the 1950s, the organisation began to lose political
influence, a change symbolised by the fact that John Diefenbaker proved to be
Canada's last Orange prime minister. Its male membership in 1984 stood at just
over 14,000 in 616 lodges, a significant drop from the more than 58,000 members
and 4000 lodges which made up Canadian Orangeism in 1955. (GOLOWret 1985; ICGW
1955) Thereafter, particularly in its Ontario heartland, a slow but steady
decline set in. Today, the organisation is dwindling and is viewed as an
interesting survival from another age. (Houston & Smyth 1980: 162-3)
By contrast,
owing to stable or rising membership during 1920-65, the Order's presence in
Northern Ireland neatly parallels its former influence in Ontario. Thus the
Order maintains an influential presence in both civic and provincial politics,
with many Belfast city councillors (including mayor Stoker), and nearly all
Ulster Unionist Party MPs counting themselves as members. In addition, its
200-year history, 45,000-strong Ulster membership, and its position on the
Ulster Unionist Council ensure that the Orange Institution is a significant
political and social player in Northern Ireland. This is highlighted annually
during its more than 4,000 July Twelfth parades - including the highly
controversial Garvaghy Road route at Portadown. Such a profile provides a
definite contrast with Ontario, where the Order's July Twelfth parades arouse
little excitement, while few of those under fifty are familiar with the
organisation.
Therefore, the
Order's elderly Canadian alumni hold the key to a puzzle of
(post?) modernisation: what caused the
decline of the Orange Order, a structural backbone of Anglo-Canadian dominant
ethnicity? Secularisation would appear to be a promising explanation, and it is
among the factors listed by Cecil Houston and William Smyth in their
speculations about the reasons for the Order's demise. (Houston & Smyth
1980: 170-71) Yet this can serve at best as a partial answer, since Orange
decline preceded the decline in Canadian Protestant religiosity by some twenty
to forty years. Value change, in a liberal-egalitarian direction, offers a
competing explanation behind the decline, as does a more general decline in the
prestige of British Loyalism. To some extent, this has been borne out by recent
survey research concerning the decline of Loyalism in Canada. (Schwartz 1967:
74-6, 106-123; Cheal 1980)
On the other
hand, techno-economic rationality, immigration (or some other variable) might
turn out to be critical - and all are offered as competing hypotheses by
Houston and Smyth in their concluding chapter. In many ways, therefore, the
puzzle of Orange decline in Canada touches upon the very questions which lie at
the heart of debates in empirical political and social theory.
Theoretical
Context
Social and
Political Theories
This research
intersects with three major theoretical discourses: social/empirical political
theory, social capital/social movements theory, and ethnicity/nationalism
theory. The analysis attempts to explain why a 150-year old organisation at the
centre of one society can enter into sudden decline, while remaining stable in
other places. It also tries to determine, more generally, which forces drive
the growth and decline of a large-scale social movement over place and time.
The Orange Order has been much more stable over the past two centuries than
more radical organisations like the Scottish Protestant League, American
Protective Association or (Canadian) Equal Rights Association.
Furthermore, the
Orange Order's existence as a traditional fraternity exactly parallels that of
the modern period, thereby providing an interesting window into the interplay
of tradition and modernisation. A stable organisation like the Orange Order
likewise provides a good yardstick for assessing the transition from industrial
modernity to post-industrial or 'high' modernity (Giddens 1991). If Orange
membership and political influence rose with modernisation but declined with
the advent of post-industrial modernity, this suggests that there may be
something qualitatively different about this 'post-modern' phase.
Another
implication of this project for social theory concerns the cause of
fluctuations in Orange membership and power. Here, one axis of debate centres
around whether the engine of social change is the techno-economic 'base' of
society (the position held by orthodox Marxists and many rational choice
theorists) or its cultural-symbolic 'superstructure,' the explanation favoured
by many in the Durkheim-Weber tradition (Inglehart 1990). For these theorists,
changes in norms and worldview are the leading driver of change. To these
'economistic' and 'culturalist' theories, one must add the more recent
empirical political theories which ascribe independent causal power to
institutional processes (i.e. March & Olsen 1984). Finally, empirical
political theorists also highlight the causal impact of events like the First
World War or Watergate scandal in recasting established worldviews or reframing
economic and political structures.[3]
Social Capital and Social Movements Theory
Debates
in social theory have their correlates in social movements theory, particularly
in the work of Robert Putnam. Putnam's recent research, using American data,
attempts to explain the decline in social capital, or voluntary association, in
the United States. Fraternal societies (like the Orange Order or Freemasons),
Putnam notes, are amongst the hardest hit by recent developments. Putnam traces
a membership profile for thirty-two American chapter-based associations which
charts a trend of steadily rising membership through 1900-1957, a plateau
during 1958-68, and a period of steady decline post-1969. (Putnam 2000: 54,
438-45)
In the first half
of the century, only the depression interrupted a steady growth in voluntary
organisations, as Americans became ever more involved in associational life.
However, Putnam posits that half the general post-sixties decline in
organisational vitality is attributable to the replacement of a 'civic' generation
of joiners born before 1940 with more privatised cohorts born after that date.
Thus a generation reared during a time of depression, war and optimism proved
more willing to join associations than its post-modern progeny. Television,
changing gender roles and suburban sprawl - with their attendant privatising
effects - contribute a further 25-40 percent towards Putnam's explanation of
decline. (Putnam 2000: 284)
Other Departures
in the Theory of Fraternal Organisation
A
number of challenges to Putnam's thesis have emerged in the literature since he
published his ground-breaking article in 1995. One of the more important with
respect to fraternalism is David Beito's recent analysis of life insurance
fraternities in the U.S. Beito's exhaustive analysis of the social welfare
provisions of numerous fraternal orders suggests that decline set in far
earlier than the 1960's. For life insurance fraternal orders - a category which
encompasses most of the larger Orders - such as the Moose, Eagles and Masons, the
sustained trend of post-Civil War membership growth began to slow by the
1920's. Beito suggests that rival entertainment sources such as radio, the
automobile and the movies were one source of the slowdown. Changing cultural
values which derided core fraternal idioms like thrift, mutual aid and
character-building, were also responsible. Finally, predatory state
legislation, which favoured state and commercial insurers, drove fraternities
from the social welfare field. (Beito 2000: 204-5)
Meanwhile,
immigrant-dependent associations lost membership as the restrictive 1924
National Origins Quota Act took effect. According to John Higham, the new
shared American working-class culture of the thirties acted as an assimilating
solvent. 'All the institutions of ethnic culture weakened,' Higham remarks. 'Lodges
declined, ethnic ceremonies and theatres faded…and in their churches and
newspapers a younger generation of priests and editors began to encourage a
greater use of English.' (Higham 1999: 53, emphasis added)
Whereas
Putnam views the sixties as the plateau before the decline, Beito considers the
twenties as the membership hiatus which heralded a subsequent avalanche of
decline. As evidence, Beito notes that the ranks of the six largest orders
stressing sick and funeral benefits fell from 7.2 million in 1930 to 5.9
million in 1935 and - despite the end of the depression - continued to tumble
to 4.7 million in 1940. Meanwhile, life insurance orders saw their total
membership slide from 10.1 to just 7.8 million Americans during the same
period. (Beito 2000: 222-23) Even the mighty Masons peaked at their staggering
12.1 percent of native-born white American adults in 1930. (Dumenil 1984: 225)
The case of the
largest association in Canada, the Independent Order of Oddfellows (IOOF), is
instructive: J.C. Herbert Emery's analysis of lodge registers in British
Columbia and Ontario shows that the IOOF grew rapidly until the 1920's, but
during this decade, initiations slumped from 11 to 3 percent. In contrast to
Beito, Emery discounts fraternal insolvency, government legislation and both
union and commercial insurance as contributing factors. Instead, rising income
among younger men, Emery suggests, allowed them to insure themselves without
having to join a fraternity. Together with recreational competition, this
spelled the beginning of the end for large fraternities like the Masons, IOOF
or the Orange Order. The trend is particularly noticeable in the cities, where
insurance and recreational competition was keenest and IOOF membership rates
lowest. (Emery 1999: 40, 44)
Though differing
widely in their interpretations of decline, most analysts of fraternal
organisation point to a combination of cultural factors (i.e. changing
attitudes or recreational tastes, generational change), economic influences
(i.e. rising income, new technologies like the car or television, new
recreational outlets), institutional forces (i.e. growth of welfare state,
fraternal scandal) and events (i.e. world wars). However, as with Houston and
Smyth in the case of Canadian Orangeism, few analysts have made a concerted
attempt to weigh the relative importance of various factors.
Ethnicity and Nationalism Theory
Some of the most
important work on fraternalism stresses the importance of changing conceptions
of gender, class and race in accounting for the rise and fall of fraternal
lodges. (Carnes 1989; Clawson 1989) Though admittedly a culturalist statement,
it is nevertheless a truism that one of the hallmarks of ritualistic
fraternalism in the first half of the twentieth century has been its ethnic
homogeneity. As agents of 'bonding' social capital, fraternal organisations -
whether immigrant/ethnic, black or WASP maintained a remarkably homogeneous
membership base.[4] In the
United States, as in Canada, IOOF members were largely - if not exclusively -
drawn from the declining Anglo-Protestant majority. (Dumenil 1984: 115-47;
Emery 1999: 31)
Meanwhile both
the IOOF and Freemasons endorsed the defensive ethno-nationalism which gripped
WASP America between 1890 and 1925. The rise and fall of the largely
northern-based, multi-million member 'second' Ku Klux Klan between 1915 and
1928 - a more moderate and mainstream organisation than either its predecessor
or successor - should give us pause when dismissing shorter-term explanations
of fraternal change. The same must be said for other 'nativist' ethno-national
movements like the Immigration Restriction League, million-plus member American
Protective Association or the Native American Party - which won several state
elections and threatened to win at the federal level in the 1850's. (Kaufmann
2002; Higham 1955 [1986])
The Orange Order,
too, was at the forefront of immigration restriction and defensive nationalism,
this time on the Canadian prairies in the 1920s, a stance which continued
unabated into the 1970s.[5]
(Houston & Smyth 1980) Indeed, it is unsurprising that Protestant
fraternities should manifest dominant ethnic tendencies given that these
sentiments were all but universal among the Protestant middle and lower strata.
Moreover, at every level, Protestants maintained higher rates of associational
activity than Catholics, so fraternalism provided an obvious outlet for
defensive middle and working-class ethnic sentiment. (Anderson 1970: 118-19)
At a more
middle-range level of analysis, ethnicity/nationalism theorists are concerned
with the question of whether ethnicity, dominant or otherwise, tends to decline
in high modernity. This scholarly discourse cuts to the question of whether
ethnicity is a transitory phenomenon, thrown up by improved communication
systems between smaller clan units, that will disappear with the extension of
those communication systems beyond the confines of the ethnie. 'Evolutionists contend that ethnic groups will be superseded in the future, while
'revivalists' see ethnic groups as more persistent.
One school of
thought, modernisation theory, holds that ethnic decline forms part of the
general trend away from kinship-based forms of 'traditional' social
organisation. (Durkheim 1893; Parsons 1951; Deutsch 1953; Kerr 1960; Hechter
1975: 22-9). To some degree, Steve Bruce, a leading authority on comparative
Protestant politics, subscribes to this viewpoint, claiming that Protestant
hegemony in Britain and North America has declined due to the combined impact
of secularisation, Protestant schism and structural differentiation (Bruce
1998). Might these forces have led to Orange decline in the latter half of the
twentieth century? Our analysis will shed important light on this question.
Since the 1970s,
modernisation theory has been eclipsed as the main paradigm in ethnicity and
nationalism theory by more conflict-based approaches (Smith 1981; Horowitz
1985). These advance the notion that ethnic groups either resist decline or increase their social importance in
post-industrial modernity. This is prompted by improved methods of
communication, which facilitate greater group consciousness. This occurs
because ethnic media and education networks become both more intensive and more
extensive, all within an atmosphere of increased awareness of other groups.
This paradigm would construe Orange decline as either temporary, or as an
aspect of the 'translation' of Protestant tradition from the Orange Order to
new social constellations like sports teams or Unionist marching bands (Bell
1990; Bairner 1997). Here again, the analysis will try to assess the relative
merits of these two main approaches.
Research
Methodology
The quantitative portion of this research is
based on an examination of Orange Order membership figures for all years
available since 1900, broken down geographically (nationally, and by province,
county, and district). The quantitative analysis is complemented by a
qualitative dimension, including interviews with Orangemen and women, lodge
reports, lodge newsletters and city newspapers. The goal being to grasp some of
the more complex influences on Orange membership as well as to provide a
subjective perspective on the dynamics of Orange political power.
It is important
to recognise that Orange Order data has generally not been available to
academic researchers and that the data presented here have never previously
been published. Due to privacy agreements with several Grand Lodges, certain
membership figures will be omitted from the analysis. It should also be
stressed that this research is still at an early stage, with a significant body
of both Orange and census data still awaiting collection, digitisation, and -
where boundaries change or are incongruent - GIS interpolation. Consequently,
missing data restricts the scope of our present model. Even so, current data
has already furnished a wealth of important material, some of which will be
presented here.
Current Findings
Since I have already published material from
my qualitative research[6],
I will concentrate on quantitative trends in Orange membership in relation to
variables from the census, historical events and, in the case of Northern
Ireland, political fatalities.
International Overview
Figure two presents a time-series portrait of
membership trends in Newfoundland, Ontario, Scotland and the three Northern
Ireland counties for which we have data. The first point to notice is that
membership density, i.e. the
proportion of the Orange target population (male British Protestant population
over the age of eighteen) that is in membership, fluctuates greatly over both
time and place. Secondly, it is clear that membership density in Scotland is
relatively weak, despite popular perceptions. This is not merely an artefact of
Scottish Orangeism's concentration on the West Coast since even in the most
heavily Orange zone comprising Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Ayrshire and Renfrewshire,
membership densities for this period do not exceed two percent. Only in a few
selected areas, like Glasgow's Govan ward or Rutherglen district, to the
southeast of the city, do densities approach those of Ontario.
The
upshot is that Canada was a far more Orange place than anywhere else outside of
Northern Ireland. Moreover, while Ontario's membership density was similar to
Belfast's until World War I, Newfoundland's far outstripped that of the three
eastern Ulster counties for which we have good time-series data. In fact, only
Co. Fermanagh and parts of Co. Tyrone and Co. Armagh can approach Newfoundland's
peak 1920's density of more than one-third of adult male Protestants in
membership. (See fig. 2)
Source: Grand
Lodge and County returns and reports.
A second feature
of Orange membership trends is the pattern of twentieth century decline. In
Canada, this dates to the 1920's. However, in Northern Ireland and Scotland,
absolute declines set in much later. Northern Ireland membership only began to
trend downward in the mid-sixties, while Scotland did not see a downturn until
the mid-eighties. Furthermore, local variation is significant: Belfast resisted
decline until the early seventies, then dropped sharply while Antrim and Down
crested in the early fifties, and slipped gradually downward thereafter. In the
rest of Northern Ireland - particularly mid-Ulster - decline was, and is, far
less noticeable. At the macro level, decline occurred first and most severely
in Ontario, followed by Newfoundland, Northern Ireland and Scotland.
Source: Grand
Lodge and County returns and reports. Note that these figures are raw
membership figures, unlike those in figure 2, which are adjusted for male,
adult, British-Protestant population.
Explaining
Membership Fluctuation
'Native born Canadians,' declared
Canadian Grand Master Gordon Keyes, 'and indeed new Canadians from the British
Isles…find difficulty in devoting time to lodge affairs. Perhaps the ever
increasing attitude of materialism, or selfish attainment contributes to
neglect of our heritage….' (Keyes IGCW1964: 30) Commentary such as this,
along with interviews I have conducted with both elite and rank-and-file
members, helps to define the parameters of the problem.
Indeed, combining
feedback from respondents, Orange documents and secondary historical literature,
the list of possibilities for explaining recent decline includes the following:
1) cultural: decline of
Anglo-Protestant ethnic hegemony, rise of non-British immigration, decline of
religiosity, ecumenism/decline of sectarianism, changing gender roles, rise of
Canadian/Scottish nationalism, declining support for Monarchy/Britishness, and
rise of liberal-egalitarianism; 2) social:
decline of social capital/connectedness, rise of alternative forms of
recreation and conviviality, declining appeal of ritualistic activities; 3) economic: rise in shift work,
suburbanisation and geographic mobility, increase in income, spread of
television/radio/automobile/telephone, depression, unemployment, industrial
decline, slum clearance; 4) institutional:
increases in lodge dues, organisational apathy, organisational schism, growth
of government functions; 5) event-driven:
World Wars, Depression, political violence, diplomacy and constitutionalism
(i.e. Good Friday Agreement, Royal Bilingualism and Biculturalism Commission),
and cross-community political events (such as new Northern Ireland Police Force
or papal visit to John Knox's statue) .
The richness of
these theories is evident: they could not have been generated by quantitative
techniques. However, in order to winnow down the large number of possible
drivers of Orangeism's rise and decline in the twentieth century, I believe
that it is imperative that we next to turn to statistical strategies. We cannot
address all of the above possibilities just yet, but the analyses to follow
will go some of the way toward underlining the most promising hypotheses.
Ontario
Our first port of call on the route to
understanding twentieth century Orangeism's trajectory is Ontario. There is a
fairly good set of annual data for many socio-economic indicators in the
province, especially for the post-1945 period. Moreover, some indicators reach
back into the early decades of the century. Figure 1 shows the results of
multiple regression analysis across all 52 available years for 1910-1961. Here
adult male Orange density (y) is regressed on the following available data: 1)
Proportion of the provincial population that is British-origin and Protestant
[gbprot] - this provides an indirect measure of the Catholic population as
well; 2) Passenger auto permits per capita [auto]; 3) Proportion of eligible
pupils attending K-12 education [propsch]; 4) Proportion of eligible pupils
attending K-12 education ten years ago [propschlag10]; 5) World War I [WWI]; 6)
Great Depression [Depr]; 7) World War II [WWII]. Variables for lags of 1, 5, 10
and 20 years for war and depression have been included as well. Finally, I have
created a variable for the interaction between war and education [impact of
wars*proportion in school], along with associated 10 year lags.
SPSS
stepwise model total and partial correlations (R-squared) are reproduced below
from most important variable to least (all variables are significant in this
paper unless otherwise noted):
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Standard Error |
Significance (Sig) |
Propschlag10 |
Proportion
of eligible pupils attending K-12 education ten years ago |
-.979 |
.000 |
.000 |
Auto |
Passenger
auto permits per capita |
-.889 |
.008 |
.000 |
WWI |
World
War I |
.449 |
.001 |
.000 |
WWIlag1 |
World
War I - one year aftermath |
.430 |
.000 |
.010 |
Deprlag10 |
Depression
- ten year aftermath |
-.289 |
.001 |
.032 |
WWIIlag10 |
World
War II - ten year aftermath |
.148 |
.000 |
.000 |
Model Total: |
|
.994 |
.00183 |
|
This model for 1911-61 predicts Ontario
Orange density almost perfectly (.994), and it is clearly the case that
education levels of ten years ago play the most important role in this
predictive power, with passenger auto permits running a close second. Both of
these modernisation variables have a strongly negative effect on Orange
density. Conversely, the World Wars tend to have a stimulating effect - whether
this takes place immediately, as in the case of World War I (+.449), or some
years thereafter (WWIlag1, WWIIlag10). Finally, the Great Depression is shown
to have a weak effect on membership, and this only after ten years.
Removing
post-1945 trends from the analysis (N=36) reduces the impact of the ten-year
education lag to -.735 and elevates the effect of WWI lag 1 to .836 and
depression lag 10 to .567. The British-Protestant proportion of the population
takes on importance at .706 while World War I itself correlates with Orange
density at .646. Post-1940 analysis (N=23) yields an increase in the proportion
of the variation explained by education lag10 to -.812, and the
British-Protestant proportion of the population takes on a very high partial
correlation of .980. This is interesting, for it demonstrates that, if
anything, the Catholic population in Ontario was rising at a time when Orange
fervour was in decline - rather than the (expected) reverse relationship.
Later, we shall see that this conclusion needs to be qualified by region.
The Role of Structural Forces
Rather than take
these results at face value, it is important that we consider the role played
by socio-economic data collected only after 1928. Unfortunately, this will
reduce our number of cases from 52 to 32 and therefore exclude years up to 1928
when Orange densities rose and then began to fall. The impact of World War I is
thereby largely occluded. However, this exercise will increase the number of
independent variables in our model considerably. SPSS model total and partial
correlations (R-squared) are reproduced below from most important variable to
least (all variables significant):
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Standard Error |
Significance (Sig) |
Propschlag10 |
Proportion
of eligible pupils attending K-12 education ten years ago |
-.980 |
.000 |
.000 |
GBProt |
Proportion
of the population of British ethnicity and Protestant faith |
.949 |
.006 |
.000 |
Depr |
The
Great Depression, 1929-33 |
.679 |
.000 |
.000 |
WW2lag10 |
World
War II - ten year aftermath |
.646 |
.000 |
.000 |
War_Inc |
Effects
of War, interacting with Income per capita |
-.537 |
.442 |
.006 |
WW1lag10 |
World
War I - Ten year aftermath |
-.514 |
.000 |
.009 |
Warlag10_ed lag10 |
Interaction
of 10-year lags of wars and proportion in K-12 education |
.484 |
.000 |
.014 |
War_Ed |
Interaction
of wars and proportion in K-12 education |
.396 |
.000 |
.05 |
Model Total: |
|
.998 |
|
.00047 |
Once again,
education of ten years ago (-.980) proves the most important factor in a model
that now includes additional variables for per capita social security payments,
old age pensions, mothers' allowances, personal income, retail sales, chain
store sales, labour wages and salaries, manufacturing wages and an industrial
composite employment index.[7]
The most important point to notice here is the striking absence of economic
variables in our explanation. Only the interaction of war and income plays a
role, and a rather meek (-.537) one at that.
In the previous
analysis of the 1910-61 period, we noted that as we approached the more recent
period, the proportion of British-Protestants begins to attain significance.
Thus it is that we find that for the post-1928 period, this factor becomes very
(.949) important. The positive direction of the relationship suggests that the
decline in WASP demographic preponderance may have signalled a more general
decline of dominant-group ethnicity. This might account for the lack of Orange
response to the growth of the non-British, non-Catholic population in this
period. It may also suggest that more liberal attitudes among
British-Protestant Ontarians helped to lower barriers to Catholic immigration.
Evidently, more research is needed to substantiate this hypothesis.
In terms of
events, the Great Depression is most important, and it coincides with an
improvement of Orange density, at a partial correlation of .679. This is
difficult to interpret, but it is probably the case that lodges' practice of
making allowance for unemployed members during the depression temporarily
reduced the rate of suspensions for non-payment of dues and thus masked the
trend of sharp membership decline which characterized the 1920-1939 period.
World War I's
ten-year lag effects can be discounted for this post-1928 period due to limited
data points, despite the fact that its ten year lag reaches the first few years
of this model at a partial correlation of -.514. World War II also shows little
effect, but its ten-year aftermath correlates well (.646) with a revival of
Orange membership - something noticeable in other provinces as well. Perhaps
this phenomenon is related to Robert Putnam's observation that associational
life in general picked up strongly in the decade after the second world war.
Despite the low number of cases (N=32), it seems that education and
dominant-group ethnicity are our best predictor of Orange density while
economic and event-driven variables contribute little to our explanation.
The median individual in K-12 education ten
years ago is of prime age (21-22) for lodge initiation, and it may be the case
that the education system began to act as a socialising agent for values that
were antithetical to Orangeism as early as the turn of the century. Given the
officially pro-British imperative in Canada around this time, it is doubtful
that Canadian nationalism or anti-monarchical sentiment played a role.
(Schwartz 1967) Instead, the most likely focus of counter-Orangeism would be
religious toleration for Catholicism and, less convincingly, ethnic tolerance
of French Canada. Indeed, historical research in the United States and Britain
has demonstrated that Protestant sectarianism fell out of favour among the
educated middle class and cultural elites by the turn of the century and had
begun to pass from school textbooks around this time as well. It would be
surprising if English-speaking Canada did not participate in this trend.
(Fitzgerald 1979; Ingram 1988; Waller 1988; Bruce 1998: 119)
The high partial
correlation for British-Protestant ethnicity and Orange density can be slotted
into this explanation, since an ethnically assertive British-Protestant
population would be expected to demonstrate strong antipathy to non-British,
Catholic population growth. Here we would expect a negative, rather than
positive, correlation between the British-Protestant share of the population
and Orange density. Yet our findings suggest the opposite: as the Catholic
population increased through French-Canadian migration, European immigration
and a higher Catholic birthrate, Orangeism actually weakened among
British Protestants.
It is certainly
possible that the growing Catholic presence may have forced Protestants to be
more accommodating. Indeed, this was somewhat evident in the United States,
where the second Ku Klux Klan flourished in Protestant-majority sections of
Protestant states like Oregon and Indiana, but fared more poorly in mixed
regions of more diverse states like Illinois. (Moore 1991) On the other hand,
this is a counterintuitive result that our cross-sectional and comparative analyses
will cast doubt upon. More than likely, the high correlation has partly been
produced because a third factor related to modernisation (be this liberalism or
economic growth) prompted a decline in both Orange density and the
British-Protestant proportion of the population.
Ontario: Cross-Sectional Analysis
The preceding
analysis is consistent with a cultural explanation, but might a different story
be told if we examine data cross-sectionally as well as in time series? A
limited dataset of census information has been digitised at county level for
1911, 21 and 41. This includes data for counties in Ontario West for 1911, 21,
and 41, but - owing to missing Orange records, excludes the third of the
province under the Grand Lodge of Ontario East for the years 1921 and 41.[8]
88 cases were generated, though the number of independent variables is a great
deal more restrictive than in the time series analysis. Variables include 1)
Proportion of the provincial population that is of British origin, 2) Proportion
of the population that belongs to a British denomination of Protestantism (i.e.
may include German-origin Anglicans but not Scottish-origin Lutherans), 3)
Percentage rural, 4) Irish Protestants as a proportion of British-Protestant
population, 5) Scottish Protestants as a proportion of British-Protestant
population. Variables were also added for major non-British ethnic groups as
well as Catholics, Lutherans and Mennonites.
Evidently there
is only one variable (urban-rural) that taps an economic factor, so this is as
yet an incomplete exercise. Results of our time-series cross-sectional analysis
appear below:
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Standard Error |
Significance (Sig) |
ProtIre |
Proportion
of British-Protestant Population that is of Irish origin |
.355 |
.001 |
.018 |
Rural |
Proportion
rural |
.334 |
.002 |
.010 |
Dutch |
Proportion
Dutch origin |
-.294 |
.007 |
.000 |
Lutheran |
Proportion
Lutheran |
-.241 |
.027 |
.000 |
Baptist |
Proportion
Baptist |
-.239 |
.029 |
.000 |
Model Total |
|
.555 |
.01073 |
.000 |
This is a weaker
model than we saw in the purely time-series analysis, though this can partly be
explained by the large number of cases contained therein, as well as the lower
degree of linearity in cross-sectional models. Notice that at the
cross-sectional level, there is no variable that predicts the trajectory of
Orange density as powerfully as education (lag10) or British Protestant
population does in the time series case. Nevertheless, it is interesting that
across our 88 cases, the best predictor is Irish Protestant ethnicity.
Conversely, Scottish Protestants as a proportion of the British population are
not a significant predictor of Orange density. The overall importance of Irish
Protestant ethnicity as late as 1941 suggests that there remained an element of
'immigrant association' within the Orange Order despite the fact that the
organisation clearly transcended its Irish-Protestant roots. (Houston &
Smyth 1980; Senior 1972) Future work with nominal census data and lodge roll
books should expose the degree to which the Irish were over-represented within
Ontario Orangeism.
The proportion of
rural population was next in importance to Irish Protestantism, though it was
not used as the initial predictor by the model. Clearly, more variables need to
be added in order to determine the importance of this factor in relation to
other aspects of structural modernisation. Comparison across 39 cases in 1911,
where we have data for the entire province and include variables for population
density and population growth, leads to the removal of the rural variable
entirely. In fact, besides Irish Protestantism, only Dutch has a partial
correlation of any significance, though the model deemed it too statistically
suspect to include. Perhaps it is the case that the rural-urban variable takes
on greater importance after 1911 or in Ontario West, but it is also possible
that its effects may be displaced or dissipated by the addition of further
structural variables.
Turning to the
less powerful factors, it is a puzzle as to why counties with higher than
average Dutch or Lutheran populations might have lower Orange densities within
their British-Protestant populations. Perhaps these Protestant minorities may
exert a salutary effect on cross-community relations, thereby ameliorating the
stark Protestant-Catholic paradigm. It is also possible that Baptist, Dutch and
Lutheran populations gain influence over the model due to the skew in the data
towards western Ontario. This is particularly true for Baptists since they are
over-represented in south-western counties around London where 'late Loyalists'
and other immigrants from the United States settled early in the nineteenth
century. (Errington 1987) The fact that all three variables disappear from the
analysis of 1911 (N=39), goes some way toward endorsing this view.
The
above analysis further indicates that the proportion of French and Catholic
population in a district does not seem to be as significant as one might have
expected. However, when one examines figures for the seventeen counties of
Ontario East in 1911 (recall that this is the only year for which we have
Ontario East Orange data), the model's only important variable is the
proportion of the population of French origin, which correlates at .609 with
Orange density. Moreover, narrowing the focus to the 11 easternmost counties in
the province raises the model's predictive power to .571, and, most
importantly, brings the proportion of Roman Catholics to the fore as the main
predictor of Orange density. The correlation is significant at .759.
It is well-known
that French-Canadian migration into eastern Ontario was an important
precipitator of low-level ethnic conflict in the mid-nineteenth century, and it
may well be that this legacy persists most strongly in the easternmost counties
of southern Ontario. Yet these are also counties which contain higher than
average proportions of Catholics. Could it be that Protestants in counties with
Catholic populations above a certain threshold tend to be more likely to
respond in an Orange fashion to higher Catholic populations? An analysis of the
twenty cases where Catholics form at least 20 percent of the population
(irrespective of region) indeed shows this to be the case. For these counties,
Catholic percentage is the best predictor of Orange density at a partial
correlation of .746, followed by the proportion of British ancestry at .592.
Ontario Summary
First of all, it is important to note that we
have yet to build up a comprehensive model that contains cultural, structural
and event-driven variables in both time-series and cross-section. Nonetheless,
from our evidence to date, it appears that the Irish share of the British
Protestant population is our best cross-sectional predictor. It has a
consistently high correlation and appears in every large model that was run. As
we approach counties with Catholic populations above twenty percent, it appears
that the proportion of Catholics supersedes Irish-Protestant ethnicity as the
main predictor of Orange density.
Finally, the
proportion of British origin appears, if anything, to be linked to higher
Orange densities. An interpretation of these patterns might be that Irish
Protestant ethnic tradition tends to maintain Orange density in strongly Irish
and Protestant western counties like Dufferin, Bruce and Simcoe. In those
northern and Quebec border counties of the province where Catholics form a
higher proportion of the population, the Protestant imperative supplants
Irish-Protestant ethnic tradition as the motor of Orangeism. We also cannot
rule out the role of structural modernisation, since the proportion of rural
population is important in our model. However, the addition of just a small
number of extra structural-demographic variables in 1911 seems to dissipate the
impact of this factor, so it is not clear how effective it really is.
Returning
to our time-series analysis, it becomes evident that education levels comprise
the most important part of the story when it comes to dissecting temporal
patterns of Orange membership. They seem to exceed structural variables and
events in importance at nearly every turn. World War I and its effects were of
moderate importance - stimulating Orangeism during and immediately after the
war, but abetting decline ten years later. The rising proportion of Roman
Catholic and non-British population in Ontario does not appear to have led to
heightened Orange activity among Protestants. On the contrary, it seems to have
dampened Orange density. On the other hand, this certainly is not the case at
the cross-sectional level. Later on, with the benefit of a comparative
perspective, we shall address this seeming anomaly between time series and
cross-sectional findings.
Newfoundland
Though Newfoundland's Orange membership was
less than a third of Ontario's at its peak, this colony/province had a per
capita rate of lodge membership that was 3 to 6 times higher than Ontario. This
makes it an important province for consideration. Unfortunately, Newfoundland's
late entry into Canadian confederation means that comparable annual statistics
do not appear until after 1949. Only data on education, ethnicity, religion and
population exists in annualised form for the period 1920-49. Furthermore, we
have yet to collect Orange membership data for the post-1965 period. Finally,
pooled time-series cross-sectional analysis has been delayed due to the need to
correct for changing census boundaries between 1911, 1935 and 1949. Using a
limited time-series model for 1920-62 that only includes religion and education
as independent variables, we get a model r-square of .692, with partials of
-.730 for proportion in K-12 education and -.395 for proportion Protestant.
Adding in similar economic data as the Ontario case reduces the number of cases
to just 12, limiting the usefulness of the data. Evidently, our best
Newfoundland model will be a time-series cross-section based on more complete
census and Orange data for the years 1911-1991.
Northern
Ireland
Time-Series Cross-Sectional Data for
1891-1971
Northern Ireland is in many ways the most
pressing of our cases, given the important political role played by Orangeism
in the province. The history of Northern Ireland since partition in 1922 has
been punctuated by cycles of peace, protest and violence. However, peace had
been the norm until the 1960's. Only the immediate post-partition period and
the IRA's modest border campaign of 1956-62 punctuated the relative calm
engendered by the Protestant-dominated Stormont regime. This period witnessed
sustained economic development and industrialisation in Northern Ireland,
including the flourishing of Belfast's famous, Protestant-dominated shipping
industry. Demographic change was also a feature of this period as the fertility
differential between Catholic and Protestant rose while emigration drew
proportionally more Catholics away from the province.
Our
county-level model for this period contains only about a third of possible
cases due to the paucity of lodge reports retained at Grand Lodge level.
Further fieldwork may help to fill the gaps in the record, particularly for the
agrarian and strongly divided mid-Ulster region and Londonderry City - both of
which are under-represented in this sample. The sample is also skewed somewhat
toward 1971, since we have a complete set of Orange data for that census year.
Notwithstanding these limitations, this is a solid dataset, with no estimated
data, which provides decent temporal and geographic coverage of the province.
Results are presented below:
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Standard Error |
Significance (Sig) |
Protpc |
Proportion Protestant |
-.736 |
.078 |
.001 |
COI |
Church of Ireland
population as a proportion of Protestants |
.579 |
.116 |
.019 |
Model Total: |
|
.757 |
.03344 |
|
Our model generates a score of .757 across 17
cases. The main predictor variables are the proportion of Protestants/Catholics
(-.736) and the proportion of adherents of the Church of Ireland (.579). Here
we find the pattern we might have expected in an atmosphere of sectarian
tension - a pattern generally absent in Ontario. Hence Orange density tends to
rise where Protestants feel their hegemony to be weaker.
The reverse
polarity attached to Church of Ireland membership is interesting. Together with
the strong negative correlation (-.666) between Orange density and proportion
Presbyterian, we must conclude that Orangeism is more prevalent in districts
where the Church of Ireland is strong. This may reflect a regional bias: the
COI is more strongly associated with English-settled regions of mid-Ulster
while Presbyterianism is more powerful in the more Protestant, Scottish-settled
eastern zones of the province. (Boal 1982)
The
absence of any significant impact from variables related to occupation,
industry, urbanisation, population density or housing stock is surprising, but
does not rule out the role of structural factors. Perhaps the higher number of
observations produced by a more detailed time-series cross-sectional analysis
at the parish/barony level may highlight such trends. For the present, though,
structural factors appear to be strikingly irrelevant when it comes to
explaining patterns of Orange activity.
Turning briefly
to the question of time-series models, we must take note of the poor state of
available membership data for Northern Ireland in the 1890-1966 period. What we
have is largely confined to the least powerful Orange areas in the eastern part
of the province. Meanwhile, data for structural variables is in the process of
digitization. Even so, we can use available and estimated membership data for
119 cases in the counties of Belfast, Antrim and Down to compare across a
minimal set of variables for political events (war, depression) and religious
composition. Doing so, we find that the proportion of Protestants is the most
powerful predictor at -.688, followed closely by the events of the partition
period of 1919-23, which have a positive impact on Orange density of .656.[9]
Here we find that, in contrast to Ontario, the religious mix is important in
both time series and cross-section, though firm conclusions must be withheld
until structural variables are added to the model.
1966-Present
The contemporary period of the 'Troubles' in
Northern Ireland begins in 1968 with the advent of the Northern Ireland Civil
Rights movement for Catholics, which led to a crisis due to the response of the
Protestant-dominated Stormont regime and the violent counter-involvement of the
IRA. Fortunately, we have obtained access to Northern Ireland membership data
for the critical period 1966-95. Time series comparison data for Northern
Ireland is still being collected and digitised, but is less comprehensive than
in the Canadian case. Currently, the model contains annual data on religious
affiliation, Protestant fatalities caused by Republican (i.e. Catholic)
terrorist organisations and male unemployment. There are also dummy variables
for three important historical events: the civil rights movement (1968-74),
direct rule (1969-72), and peace processes (1974-Sunningdale, 1985-Anglo-Irish
Agreement, 1993 - Downing Street Declaration). Once again, we must caution that
this model is missing key elements of socioeconomic and opinion poll data.
However, it is interesting to examine the results of even this, preliminary,
model, shown below.
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Significance (Sig) |
Standard Error |
Civrt |
Civil Rights Period, 1968-74 |
.707 |
.020 |
.000 |
Protfatal |
Protestant Fatalities
caused by Catholic organisations |
.565 |
.002 |
.001 |
MaleUE |
Male Unemployment |
-.556 |
.018 |
.000 |
The most glaring
result of this exercise is the relationship between religious composition and
Orange density. The Protestant proportion of the population did not emerge as
an important predictor of Orange membership. However, the zero-order
correlation between proportion Protestant and Orange density is actually
strongly positive (.770) in this period. What we find therefore is that,
in this limited model of the 1973-1995 period, Orange density tends to fall
even as the proportion of Catholics rises. This pattern matches that of Ontario
and contradicts the results of our analyses of Northern Ireland for the
1891-1971 period. Perhaps we can infer that when Orangeism is in decline (as it
is in this period in Northern Ireland), demographic changes which increase the
Catholic population do not stimulate Orange growth.
On the other hand, events and economic
factors appear more critical in the recent period since the 'Troubles' began.
The civil rights movement, for example, serves as the most powerful predictor
of Orange density in contemporary Northern Ireland at a partial correlation of
.707. One might surmise that this movement energised Orangeism - indeed,
membership rolls broke trend and began to turn upwards with the advent of this
Catholic movement. Protestant fatalities (.565) runs second to the civil rights
movement in importance as a positive predictor of Orange density. This is in
many ways unsurprising: the idea that Orangeism would be energised by sectarian
conflict seems intuitive. In some ways, one might have expected a stronger
relationship, though such a trend will be more clearly illuminated as more
cultural and economic variables are added to the model.
Lastly, male
unemployment (-.556) registers as a vital component of our analysis: it vastly
improves the predictive power of our model and serves as an important force in
dampening Orange membership. It questions the 'Protestant alienation' thesis
concerning the reduced upward mobility of Protestant workers due to industrial
decline since one might expect disaffected workers to swell Orange ranks in
protest. (Dunn & Morgan 1994) On the other hand, it is certainly possible
that Protestant alienation may have translated itself into other forms,
including paramilitaries or marching bands. (Bryan 2000; Fraser 2000)
Northern Ireland Summary
Overall,
our analysis seems to indicate that the relationship between Orange density and
religious composition changes some time around 1970. Prior to this date,
Orangeism is strengthened as Protestants become a smaller share of the
population. This is similar to what we found for high-Catholic counties in
Ontario. At first glance, the relationship is stronger in Northern Ireland
since it holds across the entire dataset, rather than merely over a subset of
it. On the other hand, when we account for the low number of cases and the
higher Catholic population in Northern Ireland, the picture in Ontario and
Ulster can be amalgamated into a general theory that Orange density is strongly
affected by the presence of a Catholic minority of more than twenty percent.
In
time-series, Northern Ireland and Ontario part company since the rising
Catholic population in Northern Ireland during 1891-1971 prompted an increase
in Orange membership. However, after 1971, the relationship between Orange
vitality and Protestant demography reverses itself and assumes the Ontario
pattern. Here, Orange decline and Protestant demographic decline proceed in
tandem. Events appear more important in the Northern Ireland case, where the
immediate post-World War I/Partition period led to a strong surge in Orange
membership. The Civil Rights movement of 1968-74 had a similar, dramatic,
result. Finally, structural factors are generally muted in Northern Ireland -
as in Ontario - with the caveat that male unemployment is of importance in the
recent period. It should also be noted that it is at present unclear whether
education levels might serve as a strong predictor of Orange density in
Northern Ireland, as they have in the Canadian case. The absence of a census
question on this matter means that we cannot rule out this possibility.
Once
again, caution is advised when it comes to investing these results with final
significance. The addition of census, household facility and opinion survey
data is needed to round out our post-1968 time series. Moreover, further field
exploration is required in order to expand upon the county-level time series.
Finally, GIS areal interpolation will allow us to combine pre- and post-1966
datasets in such a way as to surmount the administrative boundary changes of
1974. In combination with a finer-grained, parish and barony-level analysis,
this will generate a far higher number of cases for analysis - particularly for
the critical post-1966 period.
Scotland
As in the case of Northern Ireland
(time-series excepted), we have a comprehensive set of census data with which
to generate independent variables for analysis of Scottish Orange density.
Scottish Orangeism generally did not attain high levels of density. Indeed,
there is no membership at all in the Highlands or Borders regions and only
limited representation outside the west-central belt of the Lowlands. Inside
this area, though, particular Glasgow wards and certain districts of
Lanarkshire and Renfrewshire approach or somewhat exceed levels attained by
Ontario during its membership peak. It is also worth noting that the
organisation resisted decline for longer than other Orange jurisdictions, so it
forms an interesting case for comparison.
Our model in this
case is quite comprehensive in terms of
independent variables, as it includes the complete set of census, income,
electoral and registrar general data gathered by Michael Hechter for his
important work on internal colonialism in the Celtic periphery. The relative
completeness of our Scottish Orange data also helps to ensure a high number of
cases. This data thus forms our most complete time-series cross-section, with
over 50 initial independent variables prior to stepwise regression. However,
this panel data is restricted to the 1901-61 period because of boundary changes
and Orange data for which I am still negotiating access.
Furthermore,
unlike the other jurisdictions under scrutiny, the Scottish membership figures
combine male, female and junior figures. The latter two categories are much
more important in Scotland than elsewhere, accounting for as much as 50 to 65
percent of membership after 1930. Adult male membership must be estimated from
the data, and though I have done this for the time-series analysis, some
caution is necessary when considering these figures. Results from our stepwise regression
analysis for the 1901-61 period, using total rather than male figures, appear
below:
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Significance (Sig) |
Standard Error |
Ire50lag*cath |
Interaction
of Irish-born population of 50 years ago and present Catholic share of
population |
.754 |
.000 |
.000 |
Nonc_prot |
Interaction
effect between non-conformist Protestant population and Protestant share of
population |
-.604 |
.000 |
.023 |
Propeng |
Proportion
English |
-.525 |
.000 |
.034 |
Marrate |
Marriage
rate |
.495 |
.000 |
.003 |
Celt |
Proportion
Celtic speakers |
-.294 |
.039 |
.050 |
Model Total |
|
.750 |
|
|
Notice that these results appear to combine
findings from the Ontario time-series of 1901-61 and panel analyses in that
they emphasise the importance of the contemporary Catholic and Irish heritage
proportion of the population but also demonstrate a limited significance for
structural variables. Catholic and Irish heritage both tend to predict higher
Orange densities. This may point toward the maintenance of a tradition of
Orangeism within Irish-Protestant descended families, a phenomenon documented
in the literature on Scottish Orangeism in the nineteenth century. (MacFarland
1990; Marshall 1996)
The proportion of
Protestants, in interaction with the proportion of nonconformists, tends to
dampen Orangeism. Bearing in mind that nonconformists are vastly
over-represented in earlier decades, it is nonetheless interesting that
non-conformity seems to be associated with lower levels of Orange activity.
This might be due to the Orange link with established institutions like the
monarchy, but it is also probably related, like Celtic language ability, to
Scottish highland migrants, who would have had no exposure to Orange
traditions.
The importance of
the English population, which does not exceed seven percent in any of our
cases, and its negative correlation with Orange density, is uncertain.
Englishness seems to correlate moderately well with the proportion of civil
servants, those over 65 and those with higher incomes. It has a negative
relationship with birthrates, religiosity and the proportion of people in
manufacturing. Thus the influence of the English could be due to their less
sectarian worldview. They may thereby have been influential in institutions of
religion, commerce and government where they were better represented. On the
other hand, it may arise because the English proportion of the population is
somehow related to economic development. We know that the cases with the
highest proportion of English are mostly from the more recent 1951-61 period.
Meanwhile, the English are over-represented in the East and Mid-Lothians and
Fifeshire counties, which contain relatively few members.
Our most
important structural variable is marriage rate, which correlates well with
population density and proportion urban. This variable does not seem
well-correlated with economic indicators like income or occupation, so any
broadbrush conclusions about the role of industrialization must be put in
context. In addition, no data on education appears to have been collected for
Scotland in this period, hampering a direct comparison with Ontario, where this
factor was extremely significant. Finally, if we isolate male adult membership
and run the same model, we get a similar set of results across 55 cases, with
the current proportion of Irish-born (.750) and nonconformist Protestants
(-.594) as the leading explanatory variables and total population (.526) and
marriage rate (.352) as the most important structural factors.
The impact of the
'ethnic' or 'immigrant' factor, along with sectarianism, is highly pronounced
for 1901-21 (28 cases), and the best predictors are the current proportion of
Catholics in interaction with Irish-born proportion of 50 years ago (.886), and
the proportion of Celtic language speakers in interaction with Irish-born
proportion of 50 years ago (-.601). Indeed, these factors predict Orange
density to an R-squared of .836. The negative effect of Celtic language, which
we noticed in our previous analysis, probably reflects the limited appeal of
Orangeism among Highland Scots and Highland migrants - a finding which makes
sense given the absence of any Orange lodges in the Highlands. Our cases
include no data for the Highlands, and when we add in data for Argyll in 1961,
where Celtic speakers are well-represented, the importance of this variable
increases. No doubt we would find a stronger effect from this variable if we
expanded our range of cases to include the Highland counties.
Finally, the
contemporary Irish population does not appear significant, thus it is probably
the case that early-to-mid twentieth century immigrants from Ireland contained
fewer Protestants. Probing more deeply, we find that for 1901-31, the main
factors are a) interaction of Irish-born of 50 years ago and Catholic today
(.884); b) nonconformity
(-.485); and c) celtic-speakers (-.446). The
R-squared of the model is .812 across 36 cases.
An analysis of
the more recent period of 1931-61 also flags up the Irish factor: the
Irish-born population of today, interacting with the current proportion of
Catholics (partial = -463) and that of 50 years ago (.683) are selected by SPSS
as the important variables. No structural variables appear. Evidently, Irish
immigrants no longer excited a Protestant reaction, and/or failed to bring
Orange traditions with them by this time. However, our two factors only predict
Orange density at a lower R-squared of .599. On the other hand, isolating the
post-war 1951-61 period (N=19) raises the importance of the Irish-born
proportion of 50 years ago to (.909) and that of the current proportion of
Catholics interacting with Irish to (-.838).
This strong
inverse pattern between traditional and contemporary Irish-born populations
reinforces the earlier claim that traditions bequeathed by Irish Protestant
immigrants of the 1880s and 1890s - possibly within families or local networks
- rather than living anti-Catholicism, kept Orangeism vital during this period.
This fits in with patterns of twentieth century sectarian voting behaviour
detailed by David McCrone and Tom Gallagher, among others. (McCrone 1992;
Gallagher 1987) Partial correlations with population growth (-.822) and infant
mortality rate (.678) suggest that structural variables appear to take on more
importance in the post-war period.
Time Series Analysis
Given the excellent annual record of Scottish
Orange membership, it was interesting to construct a time series which employs
an interpolated variant of Hechter's variables to bridge inter-censual periods.[10]
This makes sense insofar as many variables (income, urban/rural, nonconformity,
etc) tend to trend in the same direction over time. On the other hand, these
results need to be taken with a great deal of caution given the large degree of
estimated data. The result of this exercise appears below:
Independent Variable |
|
Partial Correlation |
Significance (Sig) |
Standard Error |
Popdens |
Population
Density |
.866 |
.001 |
.000 |
WW II |
World
War II |
-.617 |
.000 |
.000 |
WW1lag5 |
World
War I - five-year aftermath |
.696 |
.000 |
.000 |
WWIlag10 |
World
War I - ten year aftermath |
.580 |
.000 |
.000 |
Deprlag1 |
Depression
- One year aftermath |
-.463 |
.000 |
.000 |
WW2lag1 |
World
War II - one year aftermath |
.430 |
.000 |
.001 |
Model Total |
|
.883 |
|
.00040 |
Despite the large amount of estimation, it is
interesting that across the 61 cases examined here (1901-61), structural
variables become more important. Population density, which is well-correlated
with urbanisation and the marriage rate, gives us our best partial correlation
(.866). Something about the move to towns and cities - more so than any changes
in the mode of production - seems to have encouraged Scottish Orange
membership. Next in importance are factors related to war and depression. World
War II itself had a dampening effect on Orangeism (-.617), but war's end
brought a positive (.430) pressure to bear on the organisation. World War I
seems to have had limited effect - this can be explained partly by lodges
keeping serving members on the books - though both five (.696) and ten years
(.580) after the British victory, Orangeism received a boost in fortunes.
The
'ethnic' factor only makes its appearance in the 1945-61 period, when Irish
population of 50 years ago, in interaction with current Catholic share of
population, explains .750 of the variance for these 16 cases. Conversely, in
the earlier 1900-45 period, the lags for 5 (.765) and 10-years (.655) of World
War I, together with population growth rate (-.609) are important. However,
before we conclude that cultural factors are silent in time-series analysis, we
need to examine figures for adult male Protestants. Main explanatory variables
here include: Catholic % of 50 years ago (-.854), World War I (-.364), World
War II one year lag (.443) and World War II's five year lag (-.398). Notice
that these figures re-establish the importance of cultural explanation and
confirm the positive stimulus for Scottish Orangeism of the end of World War
II.
Theoretical Implications
What are the theoretical implications of
these findings in comparative perspective? To some extent, firm conclusions must
be suspended until further data becomes available. Nonetheless, our single most
important finding is unlikely to be affected by additional data. Namely, that
cross-sectional analysis flags 'modernising' factors (population density,
population growth, marriage rate, education) to be more important while
cultural ones (proportion of Catholics, proportion of Irish 50 years ago,
proportion of Irish Protestants, Protestant denominational mix) have a stronger
weight in cross-sectional analysis.[11]
Northern Ireland is largely an exception, Scotland less so.
How
to explain this disjuncture? One interpretation might be that the meaning of
Irish or Catholic in time series differs slightly from that in cross-section.
After all, the change in ethnic or religious composition over time often owes
more to slow-moving fertility differentials than it does to the rapid social
change wrought by settlement and immigration. For instance, it may be that the
initial Irish and Catholic migratory patterns which established cross-county
differences in religious makeup generated considerable Orange dynamism in
Canada and Scotland. However, this is everywhere a heavily nineteenth century
phenomenon. The twentieth century witnessed a slowing of both Catholic,[12]
and especially Irish Protestant, immigration to Scotland and Canada. In
Northern Ireland, geographic differences in religious composition were
established (Belfast excluded) as early as the seventeenth century. So it is
probably not surprising that this factor predicts powerfully in cross-sectional
terms but weakly - if at all - in time series.
It
could be the case, therefore, that once the initial Irish migratory patterns
became established, community and family tradition - more so than sectarian or
ethnic conflict - maintained Orangeism's vitality. This recalls Stinchcombe's
historicist causal explanatory scheme, whereby historical templates impart
path-dependency to subsequent social organization, regardless of latter-day
sources of stimuli. (Stinchcombe 1968) In such an environment, steady
demographic change would not provide the ammunition for Orangeism's expansion.
A
similar story might be adduced from the data on religious denomination.
Nonconformity, which tends to be negatively related to Orangeism, crested in
the middle nineteenth century in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Ontario.
Settlement patterns were being established at this time which may have
entrenched the cross-sectional effects we observe. As with Catholic/Protestant
migration, it was only under the impact of rapid change that these differences
produced an Orange response. Thereafter, Orangeism became more
tradition-dependent and its membership strength tended to march more strongly
to the tune of political events or modernising variables like education or
population density.
In
terms of our theoretical mission, we might say that cultural factors appear to
take precedence over structural effects within our time-series cross-sectional
analysis. In time-series, however, our task is more difficult, since we cannot
as yet discern whether the economic, demographic or cultural aspects of
modernisation loom largest. In Ontario, where we have the best set of data,
education appears to be the premier agent of Orange time-series decline. In
Scotland, religious composition was most important for male lodges, but across
the full spectrum of Scottish membership, factors related to demographic
modernisation (marriage rate, birth rate, population growth, population
density) took precedence. In Northern Ireland, where the time-series data is
weakest, religious composition was important only for the pre-1971 period when
Orangeism developed in response to Catholic growth. After that point, political
events became the most potent predictors. War and depression, along with their
after-effects, are of moderate importance in all locations.
Evidently
political and economic variables play their part in our story. Yet were we to
try and draw an interim assessment, we need to highlight the fact that where
the data is strongest, cultural factors (education, religious composition,
ethnic composition) are the best predictors of adult male Orange membership
density. The limited impact of economic indicators (especially occupational
change and income) is another important finding. Political events and
demographic changes lie between cultural and economic variables in their
predictive power. Finally, we have seen that there is an uneven set of causal
factors operating across the four national locations: each of our jurisdictions
has a particular historical and geographic matrix which moderates the
universalising impact of our model's main explanatory variables.
Turning
from social theory to social capital theory, our analysis appears to lend
little support to Beito's argument regarding the replacement of mutual aid with
government welfare. Only in Ontario did the timing of Orange decline correspond
to the advance of the welfare state. In Scotland and Northern Ireland,
Orangeism shows little conjunction with the rise of the post-World War II
British welfare state. Even in Ontario, where the timing is right, our
time-series analysis indicates that the expansion of social security, old age
pensions and family/mother's allowances is of only limited importance in
explaining the decline in Orange density. This is not to dismiss Beito's main
premise since he is primarily addressing life insurance fraternal orders. Yet
it should serve as a cautionary note to those who would generalise his findings
beyond these organisations.
J.C.
Herbert Emery's thesis that rising income might explain fraternal decline
should also be questioned since income plays little role in our model. The
parallel trajectory of Orange and Oddfellow membership in Ontario raises the
additional question of whether Emery's model is even approporiate for the
Oddfellows.[13] On the
other hand, both Beito and Emery's observations regarding changing norms seem
plausible due to the primacy of education over structural factors like income
in explaining Orange decline. Education might be acting as a proxy for some
form of cultural change (i.e. liberalism, nationalism) that is independent of
structural modernisation. This affirmation of Emery and Beito's ideas should
not extend to changes in technology or taste, however, since Ontario Orange
membership does not decline with the rate of per capita auto permits or
correspond to Canadian movie theatre attendance growth.
Finally,
the absence of a strong dataset for the post-1961 period means that we cannot,
as yet, adequately assess Robert Putnam's thesis. Certainly the pattern of
membership in all four of our study locations seems to illustrate a steady
Putnamite pattern of decline in the post-1950's period. Yet the most critical
declines in Canada seemed to take place in the 1920's and 30's while Scotland and
parts of Northern Ireland did not experience their modern phase of decline
until the 1960's, 70's or 80's. This may be due to differing rates of
television penetration and generational turnover, but initial models for
Ontario and Newfoundland for the 1951-65 period suggest that television is less
important than the telephone in explaining Orange decline (and actually has a
positive impact on membership!). Needless to say, much more data is needed
before we can confirm this finding. Generational change likewise stands outside
the ambit of the present model, though it shall be included once we amass a
dataset that extends through to the present period.[14]
Conclusion
The
Loyal Orange Association is the most important voluntary association for the
Protestant community in Northern Ireland. This used to be the case in many
English-speaking provinces of Canada as well, particularly Ontario, New
Brunswick and Newfoundland. Indeed, our analysis of surviving Orange membership
returns suggests that the Orange Order was generally most powerful in
Newfoundland, followed by Northern Ireland, Ontario and then Scotland. Decline
has been the order of the day for the organisation in all jurisdictions since
the eighties, and in most areas since the 1950's. This process has resulted in
the elimination of the Order's political influence in Ontario and Newfoundland,
but has yet to affect the Order in Northern Ireland, where nearly all Ulster
Unionist Party MPs and MLAs are members.[15]
Our
analysis to date, though incomplete, suggests that cultural factors related to
religious and ethnic composition, as well as education, are the best predictors
of Orange membership patterns. Economic factors generally correlate poorly with
Orange membership density. Political events lie in between the cultural and
economic in their importance. This picture, however, conceals great diversity.
Cultural factors are more important across space than across time. Economic
factors play a greater role after World War II than before it. Finally,
political events are more important in Northern Ireland than elsewhere.
Depression and war had little systematic effect on membership. The only
generalisable finding is that the end of World War II buoyed membership in all
locations.
Beyond
these general effects, we can specify some surprising particular ones. First of
all, Orangeism has been in decline across all locations since the 1980's, and
across most locations since the 1960's. Northern Ireland is not an exception to
the rule. Secondly, since the advent of the 'Troubles,' religio-ethnic division
appears to have abated as a spur to Orange growth in Northern Ireland. In fact,
the decline in Ulster Orangeism is now positively associated with the relative
decline of the Protestant population - much as was the case in Ontario during
1901-61.
Finally, the role
of ethnic and religious factors (notably Catholicism or Irish-Protestant
ethnicity) is more powerful in cross-sectional than in time-series analysis.
This suggests that while sectarianism and Irish-Protestant migration flows
helped to stimulate Orange membership in the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries, this pattern no longer holds true today. Geographic differences bear
the fossils of these earlier dynamics, but now it is community and family
tradition, not Protestant-Catholic antagonism, that keeps the Orange flame from
flickering out.
REFERENCES
Primary
TO-1999 - Interviews conducted with Orange
Order and Ladies Orange Benevolent Association members, ex-members, and their
children in the Greater Toronto Area, July-August 1999.
BFST-2000 - Interviews in Belfast and Co.
Tyrone, N. Ireland, September 2000
GLAS-2000 - Interviews conducted at Glasgow,
Scotland, September 2000
GOLI - Grand Lodge of [Northern] Ireland
county reports
GOLIret - Grand Lodge of [Northern] Ireland
county returns
GOLS - Grand Lodge of Scotland reports and
media files
ICGW - Imperial Grand Council of the World
reports
CGL - Canadian Grand Lodge reports
GOLOW - Grand Lodge of Ontario West reports
and media files
GOLOWret - Grand Lodge of Ontario West
provincial returns
LOBA - Ladies Orange Benevolent Association,
Canada, annual reports
LOBA Ont. E - Ladies Orange Benevolent
Association of Ontario East, provincial returns
Adamson
[1982] 1991. The Identity of Ulster: the
Land, the Language and the People (Bangor: Pretani Press)
Bairner, Alan.
1997. ' 'Up To Their Knees?': Football, Sectarianism, Masculinity and
Protestant Working-Class Identity,' in P. Shirlow and Mark McGovern (eds.) Who Are the People?: Unionism, Protestantism
and Loyalism in Northern Ireland (London: Pluto Press)
Beito, David T.
2000. From Mutual Aid to the Welfare State: Fraternal Societies and Social
Services (Chapel Hill & London: University of North Carolina Press)
Bell, Desmond.
1990. Acts of Union: Youth Culture and
Sectarianism in Modern Ireland (London: MacMillan)
Berger, Carl. 1969. Imperialism
and Nationalism, 1884-1914: A Conflict in Canadian Thought (Toronto: Copp
Clark Publishing)
Berger, Carl.
1970. The Sense of Power: Studies in the
Ideas of Canadian Imperialism, 1867-1914 (Toronto and Buffalo: University
of Toronto Press)
Bibby, Reginald
W. 1987. Fragmented Gods: The Poverty and
Potential of Religion in Canada (Toronto: Irwin)
Blake, Donald.
1968. Canadian Census and Election Data, 1908-68. Dataset held at
Inter-University Consortium for Political Research.
Boal, Frederick and J. Neville Douglas (eds.) 1982. Integration and Division: Geographical Perspectives on the Northern Ireland Problem (London: Academic Press)
Bruce, Steve.
1998. Comparative Protestant Politics (Oxford:
Oxford University Press)
Buckner, Philip.
1998. 'Migration and National Identity in Canadian History.' Paper delivered at
Association for the Study of Ethnicity
& Nationalism seminar, London School of Economics
Burnet, Jean.
1972. Ethnic Groups in Upper Canada.
Ontario Historical Society Research Publication no.1.
Carnes, Mark C. 1989. Secret Ritual and Manhood in Victorian America
(New Haven, CT: Yale University Press)
Cheal, David J.
1981. 'Ontario Loyalism: A Socio-Religious Ideology in Decline,' Canadian Ethnic Studies, 13, 2: 40-51.
Clawson, Mary Ann. 1989. Constructing Brotherhood: Class, Gender and
Fraternalism (Princeton: Princeton University Press)
Cole, Douglas L. 1970. 'Canada's 'Nationalistic' Imperialists', Journal of Canadian Studies, Vol.V, No. 3
Coulter, Colin.
1997. 'The Beliefs of the Unionist New Middle Classes,' in P. Shirlow and Mark
McGovern (eds.) Who Are the People?:
Unionism, Protestantism and Loyalism in Northern Ireland (London: Pluto
Press), pp. 117-38
Craith,
M. Nic. 2001. 'Politicised linguistic consciousness: the case of Ulster-Scots,'
Nations & Nationalism, Vol. 7,
Part I, pp. 21-37
Deutsch, Karl.
1953. Nationalism and Social
Communication: An Inquiry into the Foundations of Nationality (Cambridge,
MA: M.I.T. Press).
Dumenil,
Lynn. 1984. Freemasonry and American
Culture 1880-1930 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press)
Durkheim, Emile.
[1893] 1984. The Division of Labour in
Society, Introduction by Lewis Coser, translated by W.D. Halls (Houndsmills
& London: Macmillan).
Dunn,
Seamus & Valerie Morgan. 1994. Protestant
Alienation in Northern Ireland: A Preliminary Survey (Coleraine: Centre for
the Study of Conflict)
Edwards, Ruth
Dudley. 1999. The Faithful Tribe: An
Intimate Portrait of the Loyal Institutions (London: Harper Collins)
Emery, J.C.
Herbert. 1999. A Young Man's Benefit: The Independent Order of Oddfellows
and Sickness Insurance in the United States and Canada, 1860-1929 (Montreal
& Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press)
Errington, Jane.
1987. The Lion, the Eagle, and Upper
Canada: A Developing Colonial Ideology (Kingston and Montreal:
McGill-Queen's University Press)
FitzGerald, Frances. 1979. America
Revised: History Schoolbooks in the Twentieth Century (Boston & Toronto:
Little, Brown & Company)
Fitzgerald, John.
1998. 'Newfoundland Referenda Campaigns of 1948,' The Beaver,
February-March, p.3
Gallagher, Tom.
1987. Edinburgh Divided: John Cormack and
No Popery in the 1930s (Edinburgh: Polygon)
Giddens, Anthony. 1991. Modernity
and Self-Identity (Cambridge: Polity Press)
Gray, Tony. 1972.
The Orange Order (London: Bodley
Head)
Hechter, Michael,
County Data for the British Isles, 1851-1961. Dataset held at UK Data
archive.
Hechter, Michael.
1975. Internal Colonialism (London:
Routledge and Kegan Paul)
Higham, John.
[1955] 1986. Strangers in the Land:
Patterns of American Nativism, 1860-1925 (2nd ed.) (New Brunswick: Rutgers
University Press)
Horowitz, Donald
L. 1985. Ethnic Groups in Conflict
(Berkeley: University of California Press)
Houston, Cecil
and William J. Smyth. 1980. The Sash
Canada Wore: A Historical Geography of the Orange Order in Canada (Toronto;
Buffalo: University of Toronto Press) 1980
Inglehart,
Ronald. 1990. Culture Shift in Advanced
Industrial Society (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press)
Ingram, P. 1988. Sectarianism in the North West of England with
special reference to class relationships in the City of Liverpool
(Unpublished PhD Dissertation, Lancashire Polytechnic)
Jamieson, Donald,
'I saw the Fight for Confederation,' in J. Smallwood (ed.), 1991. The
Encyclopedia of Newfoundland (St. John's, NF: Joseph R. Smallwood Heritage
Foundation, Inc.), vol. 3, pp. 70-104
Kaufmann, Eric.
1997. 'Condemned to Rootlessness: The Loyalist Origins of Canada's Identity
Crisis,' Nationalism and Ethnic Politics,
vol.3, no.1, (1997), pp. 110-135
Kaufmann, Eric.
1998. ' 'Naturalizing the Nation': the Rise of Naturalistic Nationalism in the
United States and Canada,' Comparative
Studies in Society and History, vol. 40, no. 4 (October), pp. 666-695
Kaufmann, Eric.
2000. 'Dominant Ethnie,' The Companion
Guide to Nationalism (London: Transaction Publishers)
Kaufmann, Eric. 2002. ‘The Decline of Sectarianism in the West?: A
Comparison of the Orange Order in Canada, Ulster and Scotland,' in N. Singh and
T. Vanhanen (eds.) Ethnic Violence and
Human Rights (Delhi: KIRS, 2002) - forthcoming.
Kerr, Clark, John
R. Dunlop, Frederick Harbison, and Charles Myers. 1960. Industrialism and Industrial Man (Cambridge: Harvard University
Press)
MacFarland,
Elaine. 1990. Protestants First:
Orangeism in Nineteenth Century Scotland (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press)
MacRaild, Donald.
1998. Culture, Conflict and Migration:
The Irish in Victorian Cumbria (Liverpool: Liverpool University Press)
March, J.G. and
J.P. Olsen. 1984. 'The New Institutionalism: Organisational Factors in
Political Life,' American Political
Science Review, vol. 78, no. 3.
Marshall, William S.
1996. The Billy Boys: A Concise History of Orangeism in Scotland (Edinburgh:
Mercat Press)
McCrone David.
1992. Understanding Scotland: The Sociology of a Stateless Nation
(London: Routledge)
Moore, Leonard J. 1991. Citizen Klansmen : the Ku Klux Klan in
Indiana, 1921-1928 (Chapel Hill & London: University of North Carolina
Press)
Moxon-Browne. 1983. Nation, Class
and Creed in Northern Ireland (Aldershot: Gower)
McCrone David. 1992. Understanding
Scotland: The Sociology of a Stateless
Nation (London: Routledge)
O'Dowd, Liam. 1991. 'Intellectuals and Political Culture: A
Unionist-Nationalist Comparison,' in Eamonn Hughes (ed), Culture and Politics in
Northern Ireland, 1960-1990 (Milton Keynes: Open University), pp. 151-73
Parsons, Talcott.
1951. The Social System (London:
Routledge & Kegan Paul).
Pennefather,
R.S., The Orange and the Black
(Toronto: Orange and Black Publications, 1984)
Putnam, Robert D.
1995. 'Tuning In, Tuning Out: The Strange Disappearance of Social Capital in
America,' Political Science and Politics,
vol. 28: 664-83
Putnam, Robert D.
2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community (New York:
Simon & Schuster)
Rasporich, A.W.
1968. 'Imperial Sentiment in the Province of Canada during the Crimean War,
1854-1856', in Morton, W.L. (ed.), The
Shield of Achilles: Aspects of Canada in the Victorian Age (Toronto:
McClelland & Stewart Ltd.)
Richard, Madeline
A. 1991. Ethnic Groups and Marital
Choices: Ethnic History and Marital Assimilation in Canada, 1871 and 1971
(Vancouver: UBC Press)
Schwartz, Mildred A. 1967. Public
Opinion and Canadian Identity (Berkeley: University of California Press)
Schwartz, Mildred
A., Public Opinion and Canadian Identity
(Berkeley: University of California Press 1967
See, Katherine
O'Sullivan. 1986. First World
Nationalisms: Class and Ethnic Politics in Northern Ireland and Quebec
(Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press)
Senior, Elinor Kyte. 1959. The Origins and Political Activities of
the Loyal Orange Association in Newfoundland (Unpublished M.A. thesis,
Memorial University of Newfoundland)
Smith,
Anthony D. 1981. The Ethnic Revival
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Stinchcombe, Arthur L. 1968. Constructing
Social Theories (Harcourt, Brace & World)
Walker, Graham.
1992. 'The Orange Order in Scotland Between the Wars,' International Review of Social History, vol. XXXVII, no. 2
Walker, Graham.
1995. Intimate Strangers: Political and
Cultural Interaction Between Scotland and Ulster in Modern Times
(Edinburgh: John Donald)
Wallace, W.
Stewart. 1921. The United Empire
Loyalists: the Beginnings of British Canada (Toronto: Glasgow, Brook and
Co.)
Waller, P. J.
1981. Democracy and sectarianism: a
political and social history of Liverpool 1868-1939 (Liverpool: Liverpool
University Press)
[1] I am grateful to the Economic and Social Research Council, which has funded the study upon which this work is based. I would also like to acknowledge the advice and assistance of J.C. Herbert Emery, Donald Blake, Cecil Houston and Henry Patterson.
[2] Though the Quebec wing was noticeably weak, even allowing for that province's low Protestant population.
[3] For the latter view, see Marwick, Arthur, War and Social Change in the Twentieth Century: a Comparative Study of Britain, France, Germany, Russia and the United States (London: Macmillan, 1974).
[4] Putnam distinguishes between 'bridging' social capital - networks which link individuals across established social boundaries, and 'bonding' social capital which tends to reinforce links within established social groups of ethnicity or class. (Putnam 2000: 22-24)
[5] In the words of the Grand Master of Ontario East: 'It is surely essential for the future of Canada that British influence remain dominant in this country and that is why we call upon the Government to formulate an immigration policy that will assure at least fifty per cent of immigrants being British.' (Grand Lodge of Ontario East 1955: 7)
[6] Please see Kaufmann, E. P. 2002. ‘The Decline of Sectarianism in the West?: A Comparison of the Orange Order in Canada, Ulster and Scotland,' in N. Singh and T. Vanhanen (eds.) Ethnic Violence and Human Rights (Delhi: KIRS); also Kaufmann, E.P. 2001. 'The Demise of Dominant Ethnicity in English Canada?: An Empirical Examination of Orange Order Decline, 1918-80,' available on project website <http://www.canadian-english.com/OrangeOrder/Orange_order_Project.htm>.
[7] Due to high collinearity among these variables, all but mother's allowances were combined into two principal components using data reduction analysis techniques.
[8] This is not very problematic since we know the ratio of lodges between Ontario East and West for this entire period, as well as membership for the years 1890-1911, 1918, and 1925-35. These show Ontario East membership to exhibit similar trends to that for Ontario West. However, for the present model, it was decided not to use estimated data.
[9] Of interest is the fact that religious composition was not the most important factor at county-level, though it had a strongly negative effect on Orange membership and was the second most important variable. Other variables in the model included World War I (.534), WWI five-year lag (.379), WWII one-year lag (.329), and Great Depression - one year lag (.305).
[10] This involves estimating data in a straight line between decennial censuses. Naturally this builds linearity into the total model, but it should not have a systematic effect on partial correlations. The fact that this model corresponds to the Ontario time series model (where there is no estimated data) in its relationship to cross-sectional findings provides an added measure of reassurance.
[11] Political events are not tested in time-series cross-sectional analysis due to ten-year inter-censual gaps which render their inclusion difficult.
[12] Whether Irish Catholic immigration or French-Canadian Catholic internal migration.
[13] I am grateful to Herb Emery for this data. Oddfellow membership trends in 20th century Ontario are a virtual carbon copy of Orange patterns - both in terms of the number of members and the pattern of growth and decline.
[14] In the absence of a body of data analagous to the American General Social Survey, we will need to specify a dummy variable for generation to cope with this problem. Additional insight will emerge through an analysis of surviving lodge roll books.
[15] It should be noted that many UUP politicians are not active Orangemen and that there have been attempts to sever the official link between the Orange Order and the UUP which runs through the Ulster Unionist Council. Such attempts at reform have met considerable resistance, however, and have generally come to naught.